Overnight Yeasted Waffles

Overnight Yeasted Waffles from Our Best Bites intro

A few months ago, my husband and I enjoyed a weekend away at one of our favorite places in Sun Valley.  It’s mostly my favorite place because of the amazing European bakery that’s right outside my door at all times.  Aside from killer bakery items, they have a fabulous cafe, and their breakfasts in particular, are a family favorite.  I instagrammed this picture on our last morning there, of my Belgian Waffles with Lingonberry Syrup and Chocolate-Hazelnut Whipped Cream.  It was as amazing as it sounds and I promptly went home and made it myself.  Only I went for an overnight yeasted waffle {insert drool here}.  If you’ve never made yeasted waffles, they’re a little different than the standard type you’re probably used to.  The batter, as can be expected from the name, has yeast in it, that works magic in a slow overnight rise.  In the morning you pop it into your waffle maker and it creates the most wonderfully textured waffle with intense flavor.  These ones are kicked up even one more notch with the addition of brown butter.  I love them.

Start with some whole milk, that’s been warmed slightly.

Whole Milk
Add in some buttermilk.  Yes, mine is super chunk-i-fied.  That’s because I made my own so it’s nice and coagulated.  If you’re ever without buttermilk, you can easily make your own by squeezing in a tablespoon of lemon juice or vinegar and then fill up your remaining cup with regular milk.  You’ll see it immediately thicken and form some clumps like this.  I like to let mine sit for a few minutes before using.

How to make buttermilk

Then sprinkle in a packet of yeast.

Yeast in Waffle Batter

And some dry ingredients.

Flour in batter

Lastly, whisk in some brown butter.  If you’ve never browned butter before, we have a great tutorial with step by step instructions.  You can find it here.

our best bites browned butter

As amazingly delicious as brown butter is, you can also use regular melted butter here if you’re in a time pinch.

Browned butter in batter

That mixture comes together super quick, and then it just needs to sit for 8-12 hours.  I might suggest if you’re going to let it sit longer than that (12-24 hours) you refrigerate it during this rest time.  This is when the yeast works its magic!

In the morning, all you need to do is whisk a couple of eggs and a little baking soda into the batter.


And pop it into a hot waffle iron.

Waffle Batter in Iron

Now, I want you to be warned that these won’t look like normal waffles at first.  They don’t puff up the way a normal batter would, and the tops actually sometimes look kind of flat and funny and you think the recipe is a total fail.

Cooked Top of Yeasted Waffels

But don’t fear!  Flip those babies over and look at that golden goodness.  They have this amazing texture, which is sort of hard to explain, but it’s almost more chewy than fluffy, and has this awesome flavor of a yeasted bread.

Flip side of yeasted waffles

I highly suggest, that even if you don’t make brown butter for the batter, you make some to drizzle on top.  Oh my gosh, amazing.

Cooked Yeasted Waffles

The waffles tear open and are incredibly soft, with the most amazing flavor.  Definitely eat one plain, hot out of the waffle iron with real butter on top before you eat it with anything else.  And then bust out the anything-else.

Inside Yeasted Waffles

I wanted to replicate those amazing waffles at the Konditeroi Bakery, so I made my own Chocolate-Hazelnut Whipped Cream.

Nutella Whipped Cream ingredients

Since these are overnight waffles, I wanted to make this cream the night before as well, so it was all ready, which is why I have an extra ingredient in here.  I’ve found that just a little bit of instant pudding mix helps stabilize whipped cream so it can sit for longer periods of time without falling.  You could use chocolate or vanilla here.  Just sift a little in (otherwise you’ll get some lumps) with some whipping cream, powdered sugar, and vanilla.

Whipped Cream

And of course we need this:


Place a big scoop of Nutella in a bowl

Nutella in a bowl

and add a spoonful of the whipped cream mixture.  We’re just lightening the mix at this point,

Nutella and Whipped cream

so go ahead and stir it right in.

Nutella lightened

Now that it’s lightened, take the rest of the cream, a few big spoonfuls at a time, and very gently fold it together (don’t stir, fold) so you keep all of the air in the cream.  When it’s combined, place it in the fridge to chill.

Folding Nutella and Cream

I also wanted a dark berry sauce to mimic the Lingonberry jam at the bakery.  My store was out of my favorite Swiss Jam, so I grabbed this Oregon Marion Blackberry from Private Selection, which was awesome.

Blackberry Jam

Warm up the jam and stir until smooth.  You can use a little bit of hot water if you need to thin it into a syrup.  Drizzle that over butter-slathered waffles and top with the Chocolate Hazelnut Whipped Cream.

Our Best Bites Yeasted Waffles with Nutella Cream

Hello gorgeous.

Yeasted Waffle Bite on Fork
I’m telling you. You will eat this once, and then dream of eating it every morning for the rest of your life.

Yeasted Waffle Bite

Whip these up and let me know what you think!

Overnight Yeasted Waffles from Our Best Bites




Flavor Pack Graphic for Post



  1. Oh, man, why didn’t you post these before Father’s Day?! 😉 Oh, well, any weekend is a great time for waffles! (Or weeknight dinner….)

  2. I had heard from the America’s test kitchen to use a little bit of corn starch in the whipping cream. Thanks for the pudding tip, that’s a great idea too! I’m thinking I should whip these up after breakfast sometime…for dinner that night! 🙂

  3. I’ve got to get my butt in gear and try a yeasted waffle sometime soon. Also, the addition of honey in fresh whipped cream will also stabilize it (though I can’t tell you exactly how long) – approximately 1 tsp per cup of cream does the trick, I usually drizzle it in while whipping. = )

  4. OH MY GOODNESS!! Those seriously look like manna from Heaven!! I think I am going to be making them for breakfast on the weekend!!

  5. Please share your Sun Valley favorite bed and breakfast! We are planning a weekend there in August and I would love your recommendations! Not to mention that this looks amazing.

  6. These sound delicious! Have you ever tried freezing the cooked waffles and reheating them in a toaster? I know it works with other recipes, but I wondered about this yeasted one.

  7. Sounds amazing! You can get lingonberry jam at Ikea or World Market if you want it to be exactly like your bakery. Lingonberry is one of our favorite jams on any kind of pancake/waffle/crepe/aebleskiver/etc!

  8. Oh my, YUM! We will definitely be trying these! About how many waffles did you get from one recipe? It would be sad to run out of batter and not have enough for the whole family.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.