Creamy Green Chili Chicken Bake

This Creamy Green Chili Chicken Bake requires just 3 main ingredients, plus a few spices, and results in shredded chicken with a velvety smooth sauce. Serve this family friendly dish over rice or other side of your choice, or even spoon it into tortillas.  Makes a 9×13 pan and serves 6. Scroll past recipe for more step by step photos and instructions!

Print
clock clock icon cutlery cutlery icon flag flag icon folder folder icon instagram instagram icon pinterest pinterest icon print print icon squares squares icon

Creamy Green Chili Chicken Bake

  • Author: Sara Wells

Description

A quick and easy recipe with minimal ingredients!  A creamy green chili sauce coats shredded chicken- perfect for serving over rice.


Scale

Ingredients

23 lbs boneless skinless chicken breasts (46 breasts)
1 teaspoon garlic powder
1 teaspoon cumin
1/2 teaspoon chili powder
1/2 teaspoon smoked paprika (optional, if you don’t have it don’t stress)
1/4 teaspoon black pepper
16oz jar green salsa (I prefer mild)
8oz cream cheese
Kosher salt to taste
Cooked rice, for serving.


Instructions

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.  Place chicken in a 9×13 pan, sprinkle with spices (except salt).  Pour entire jar of green salsa over everything.  Bake until an instant-read digital thermometer reads 165 degrees in the thickest part of the meat.

Remove pan from oven, gently scrape off any salsa off top of each chicken breast and place chicken on a cutting board.

(Note:  Basically the only other step is adding cream cheese to the sauce in the baking dish.  The following instructions are how I found the most consistent results for a smooth sauce, but read the notes section below for some other options.)

Place cream cheese in a heat-safe bowl and microwave for 20-30 seconds or more, until it is soft and easy to stir smoothly.  Ladle some of the green chili sauce from your baking pan into the cream cheese and whisk until smooth.  Add more and keep whisking.  This little process with ensure you don’t end up with lumps in your sauce!  Scrape out all the cream cheese mixture back into your baking pan and whisk everything until smooth.

Shred chicken and add back to pan, tossing in sauce.  Season with kosher salt, if needed.  Serve over rice.


Notes

Cooking Options!  I tested all of these options to find the easiest method for you.  Here are my notes! 

  1.  I’ve cut room temperature cream cheese into small squares and tossed them in the hot sauce in the pan and then whisked it together (I like the ease of not having to use another bowl to warm the cream cheese first) but some brands of cream cheese will never get smooth and you’ll end up with chunks.  You can always pop the sauce in the blender if this happens to you.
  2. I tested placing all the ingredients into a blender first (cream cheese, salsa, spices) and then pouring over the chicken and baking.  It totally works, but compared to the method outlined in this recipe, the sauce is not as smooth.  The cream cheese tends to “break” just a bit.  But it definitely still tastes great and  some of you might find this method easiest for you.
  3. I tested cooking this with *thin cut* frozen chicken breast straight from the freezer and it worked great.  It just takes a bit longer to cook.
  4. If you want this dish to cook faster, cut your chicken breasts in half horizontally, or dice into smaller pieces.  It should come to temperature in about 30 minutes.

ALTERNATE COOKING METHODS

  1. PRESSURE COOKER:  Place everything except cream cheese into your pot.  Cook at high pressure for 10 minutes.  Remove chicken.  Add cream cheese to sauce, I would suggest an immersion blender to make sure it gets smooth.  Return chicken to pot. ‘
  2. SLOW COOKER:  Place everything except cream cheese in slow cooker and cook on low for 4 hours or until chicken has reached an internal temperature of 185 degrees. Remove chicken and shred and add softened cream cheese to sauce and whisk until smooth.  I would suggest an immersion blender.

What kind of green salsa should I use in Creamy Green Chili Chicken Bake?

This is one of the easiest recipes you’ll ever make!  The main flavor component here is green salsa.  It’s a great shortcut ingredient because it has things like tomatillo, lime, cilantro, onion and garlic already in the jar.  However, not all green salsas are NOT created equal.  One of the biggest factors is the heat level.  Even different bottles of the same salsa can sometimes taste different and have different heat levels.  If you like spicy food, feel free to use a spicy green salsa.  For my family, I always make sure to buy something labeled mild.  As an example, this is a common grocery store brand that’s easily found in grocery stores:

Sprinkle Spices over Chicken

You’ll sprinkle a handful of spices over some boneless, skinless chicken breasts in a 9×13 pan.  If you don’t have all of these, don’t sweat it.  It’s totally fine to even eyeball!  Then pour the jar of green salsa right over everything.  That’s it!  Pop it in the oven.

How Long Does Green Chili Chicken Take to Bake?

Your best friend will be an instant read digital thermometer.  Simply cook your chicken until it reaches an internal temp of 165 degrees and then remove.  For average size chicken breasts, I’d say 35-45 minutes.  Thin cut will be done in about 30 and thick will take close to an hour.

Shred the Chicken

After the dish comes out of the oven, remove the chicken pieces to a cutting board and shred.  You’ll also combine a block of cream cheese to the remaining sauce in the baking dish.  I’ve outlined a couple different ways to do this is the printable recipe.

How do I serve Green Chili Chicken Bake?

My family’s favorite way to eat this is over rice.  The creamy sauce drizzles over everything and it’s warm and perfect.  I’ve had people tell me they’ve folded this into tortillas as well.  You could also try it over pasta.

 

 

If this looks good to you, here are some other dishes you’ll probably love!

Baked Creamy Chicken Taquitos
Taco Chicken
Pressure Cooker Chili-Lime Chicken
Slow Cooker Taco Chicken

14 comments

  1. I’m a huge OG fan of you and Kate. This recipe sounds right up my family’s alley, my 3 year old loves Herdez green salsa (currently):) I did have two other ideas to make this easier, first method would be the slow cooker. I make a similar recipe with chicken, cream cheese and cream of mushroom soup and serve it with rice. I dump everything in there for 4-5 hours and it’s awesome. Second method would be the instant pot, which is great for frozen chicken idea and much shorter. Throw in everything except cream cheese and add that after you’ve cooked the chicken and done a pressure release and it’s still on warm add the cream cheese and stir. Just some thoughts. But seriously I’ve never made anything from you guys that I didn’t love:0

  2. Do you think it’d be a big deal to make the sauce on the stovetop and then add in shredded chicken? I already have frozen shredded chicken. It sounds yummy. Just wondering what your thoughts are. Thanks!

  3. This looks super yummy! I make a green chili chicken in the instapot but haven’t added cream cheese. May need to try that this week. Thanks for sharing. 😀

  4. I do this recipe in the crockpot. Just throw in the frozen breasts, cover with spices and green salsa. Cook on low or high depending on how much time you have. Then I just throw the block of cream cheese on top for the last half hour. When I come back to shred the chicken and mix in the cream cheese it is the perfect consistency to mix in smooth and creamy!

  5. Made this and enjoyed it! Similar flavors to our beloved chicken roll ups (what we call your baked creamy chicken taquitos) but a little quicker. Thanks!

  6. Made this tonight for our family. It was a hit and so so easy! It will definitely get put into the rotation. Thanks for posting!

  7. Made this last night and the whole family loved it! Reminded them of a chicken enchilada recipe I used to make, without the tortillas. haha. Passing this around to friends now!

  8. I made this tonight, and we topped it with a sprinkling of of Monterey Jack cheese, chopped avocado and tomato to jazz it up a little. It was next level good! My son joked he thought it was like a Mexican Hawaiian Haystack. haha! Thanks for the easy, delicious recipe.

  9. Made this tonight using my Instant Pot and frozen chicken breasts. Also used your Instant Pot white rice recipe! Turned out great – family loved it! Thanks for all the great recipes 🙂

  10. This was excellent. Made it in the instant pot and it was so easy. Excellent flavor. Everyone ate it. Will definitely be making this again.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Comments

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.