You guys all know what starts this week, right?  No?  Then you must not be married to my husband, because I have been hearing a countdown to the start of college football season every day for several weeks now.  And while I won’t be the person spouting off stats and schedules, I do really love sports, and especially football season just because of everything that goes along with it.  Autumn is my favorite time of year, and when football season rolls around it reminds me of being in college and what a big part of campus life football was, it reminds me of crisp fall weather (even though it’s a bazillion degrees where I live right now), and now that I’m a Mom and have my own little football players, it reminds me of how fun it is to watch your kids do something they love.

And then there’s the food.  Whether you’re actually a football fan or not, games are a great excuse to get people together and eat great food!  Now, as many of you know, I was born and raised on the west coast.  Like, reeealy west coast.  I went to college in the west, spend grad school years in yet another west coast city, and then put down roots as far East as we’ll probably ever get. Idaho.  Needless to say, I am not an expert on many trademark foods of the East.  Kate and I are always extremely cautious about sharing recipes typical to a region because we know from experience that people are very passionate about their hometown eats!  (You should have seen what happened when we once posted a recipe for “Philly” cheese steaks.  Yikes.)  Pit Beef caught my eye this month because I’ve seen it pop up in 3 different food magazines and also a new cookbook I got.   I didn’t even know what “Pit Beef” was until recently (the shame!), but hey, that’s what Google is for.  Apparently it’s Baltimore’s version of barbeque.  Unlike the sweet-sauce covered, smoked bbq’s of the south, Baltimore’s version is instead grilled.  A thick dry rub of seasonings create a flavorful crusted exterior and a tender, juicy interior.  The meat is shaved paper thin and piled high on either a kaiser roll or slices of rye bread.  And there will be no sweet and tangy bbq sauces here, Pit Beef is served with a horseradish sauce (often called Tiger Sauce), and sliced onions.  These are perfect for football food, and for prepping for a crowd.

First up- the sauce.

Let me get one thing out of the way: I’ve never really liked horseradish!  But recently I had some on a steak sandwich at a restaurant and it was the fist time ever that I realized I actually really liked it with steak.  I’m still keeping it mild here, mixing up mayo, sour cream, garlic, lemon juice, salt, pepper, and a little horseradish.  You can definitely add more horseradish if you love it, or decrease it if you’re not a fan.

For the meat, most Pit Beef recipes use a top round roast that cooks on the grill for about an hour or so.  I noticed that Guy Fieri’s recipe in this month’s BHG mag uses a london broil cut and only grills for 10-15 minutes so I went with that.  You’ll still want to look for a nice thick piece of meat, preferably about 2″. You’ll rub it down with a mix of spices: onion, garlic, paprika, oregano, chili powder, salt and pepper and let it sit for at least 24 hours and up to a couple of days.

When it’s time to get cookin’ toss those on a hot grill.  If the outside starts to get a little too charred, just keep one side of the grill on, and move your meat to the side with indirect heat.

The two tricks for tender steak sandwiches are 1.  Don’t overcook your meat (mine could have come off the grill a little sooner).  You definitely want these medium-rare.  2.  Cut it across the grain as thin as you possibly can.  Overcooked, thick sliced meat will produce super chewy sandwiches that are hard to eat!

Onions are important.  Or so Google tells me.

When you’re ready to serve up, slather a little sauce on each side of a roll (or on rye bread) pile it high with sliced beef, and top with some onion slices.

The only thing you risk, is people not actually paying attention to the big game because they’re drooling over your beef sandwiches.


clock clock iconcutlery cutlery iconflag flag iconfolder folder iconinstagram instagram iconpinterest pinterest iconfacebook facebook iconprint print iconsquares squares iconheart heart iconheart solid heart solid icon

Pit Beef Sandwiches


Savory grilled beef topped and a slightly spicy, garlicky sauce come together in the perfect summer sandwich.


2 teaspoons kosher salt
1  1/2 teaspoons black pepper
1 tablespoon onion powder
1 tablespoon garlic powder
1 tablespoon paprika (use smoked paprika if you have it)
1/2 tablespoon oregano
2 teaspoons chili powder
23 pounds beef top round, cut in 2 equal pieces (often labeled London Broil, but look for a thick one)

1/2 cup sour cream
1/2 cup mayonnaise
23 teaspoons fresh lemon juice
1 garlic clove, finely minced or pressed
2 tablespoons horseradish, more if desired
kosher salt and black pepper to taste

one onion, thinly sliced
soft white rolls or rye bread for serving


Prepare sauce by whisking all ingredients together and refrigerate until ready to use.  For best results, make at least a few hours in advance, or up to a couple of days ahead of time.

For beef, combine all spices and sprinkle on meat.  Massage into all sides and then seal meat in a zip-top bag.  Store in fridge for at least 24 hours, and up to 48 hours.

Let beef come to room temperature for 30 minutes before grilling.  Heat grill to medium-high heat.  Grill beef for 6-8 minutes on each side, or until thermometer registers about 135 degrees.  If outside of beef is charring before inside is done, turn one side of grill off and place beef on indirect heat to finish cooking.  When done, cover with foil and let stand for 10 minutes before slicing.  Slice beef as thin as possible.  Spread sauce on each side of rolls or bread, pile on sliced beef, and top with sliced onions and more sauce if desired.

Makes 8 sandwiches, or 16 slider sized.

Keywords: sandwiches, beef, bbq, grill


    1. I bet it would be great- go for it! You’d just have to roast them longer, so make sure to move them to indirect heat so the outside doesn’t dry out.

  1. Funny, when we have pulled Beef or any type of beef sandwich we make a sauce slightly similar to this (no horseradish but does have poppyseeds) and we thinly slice red onions and then mix the sauce and onions (it is very saucy) and then let the onions sit for a few hours. It turns into a VERY delicious condiment that goes perfectly with the beef! We just call them Sour Cream Onions – never knew they had an origin!!! Going to try this one (but will probably mix the onions and sauce) for a get together this fall 🙂

  2. Yummy, now I’m starving!! 🙂 Love your blog and anxiously await each new post. Guess I’d better go eat one of my homemade graham crackers….thanks to you! 🙂

  3. Baltimore native here (I know, I know). I love pit beef – thanks for posting, Sara! You can also just put a glob of horseradish on the sandwich and you’re good to go. To put it in perspective, the best pit beef is usually found on the side of the road, and you just give someone three or four dollars, and they slice some beef off the side of a still-cooking piece of meat. Though the horseradish sauce looks delicious, if you’re having a big party, feel free to just put out some plain horseradish, onions, brown mustard, and bbq sauce and let people make their own creations!

    Also, I’m just going to throw it out here. Pit ham and pit turkey. Delicious.

    1. Good to hear from a native! I’m way too wimpy to put straight-up horseradish on them, but I know a lot of people who would love it!

  4. Sounds super yummy!! Since I’m a Create channel cooking show junkie, I’ve heard of it on Steven Raichlen’s BBQU or Primal Grill, but he intimidates me with all his fancy grills and smokers and so I’ve never attempted anything he grills!! LOL I’ll have to try your version. We definitely love grilling, football, and eating good food around here, so this sounds right up our alley! 😀

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Recipe rating


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.