There’s a battle brewing at my house. My husband keeps announcing that he’s cold. He puts on a sweatshirt and some slippers and he shivers and he asks me if I think he might be coming down with something (oh please, oh please, don’t let him be coming down with something–have you ever seen The Man Cold video? Welcome to my life.) Then he wanders over to the thermostat and discovers that I have turned it down to chilly, sweater-wearing levels. This is because it is still 90 degrees outside and I refuse, refuse to accept the fact that if I got a caramel apple cider from Starbucks, I would end up lying on the couch, sweating to death and wondering if we could move to a cooler climate. So then he turns the thermostat back up, higher than we normally keep it, and I wonder why the house smells like heater when it’s 90 degrees outside and I discover what he’s done and I plot buying a lockbox for the thermostat. The weather had better cool off soon, lest we find ourselves in thermostat-related couples therapy. Until then, I’m keeping it cool and baking fall goodies. Starting with Pumpkin Chocolate Chip Muffins.

You’ll need a Duncan Hines spice cake mix (check out this post to see how strongly I feel about Duncan Hines cake mixes), pumpkin puree, sour cream vegetable oil, eggs, and chocolate chips. And vanilla, but I forgot that.

And because this is NOT the Weight Watchers version, we’re adding a streusel topping made with flour, sugar, pumpkin pie spice, and butter.

Preheat your oven to 350. Line 2 12-cup muffin tins with cupcake liners and set aside. Check out these cupcake liners that I found in the cake decorating aisle of Walmart the other day!

I love that they hold their shape and have a more unique look than traditional cupcake liners.


Ignore the directions on the box. We’re getting crazy here. Place the cake mix, pumpkin, eggs, oil, and vanilla. Beat on low speed for about 30 seconds or until the dry ingredients are moistened, then beat on medium speed for 2-3 minutes, until the mixture is smooth. Add in the chocolate chips and stir until combined.

Divide the batter evenly among the cupcake liners.

Whisk together the dry streusel ingredients (flour, sugar, and pumpkin pie spice)…

and then cut in the butter with two knives until the mixture resembles coarse crumbs. Sprinkle the mixture over the muffin batter…

and then bake in the pre-heated oven for 20-30 minutes. Yes, I realize that’s a huge span of time. Without going too far off course, let me just say that my new gas oven is throwing me for a loop. I don’t know if it’s because it’s a gas oven or if it’s just because it’s a different oven than what I’m used to, but things are not baking the same and my world has been rocked to its core. The thick and fudgy Tim Riggins Brownies? Yeah, they baked in much less time and came out fluffy and cake-like when I made them this weekend. So because I’ve been reminded first-hand how widely baking times can vary, I’ve given a pretty generous window for how long these will need to bake. There are just a few things to keep in mind: 1) They will probably take longer than the cupcake instructions on the cake box (because of the pumpkin), 2) You’ll want the tops to be turning golden, 3) When you insert a toothpick into the centers to test for doneness, you don’t want anything to come back out, not even crumbs. Because you’re adding the pumpkin and the sour cream, these will be very moist, so if you underbake them at all, they will be on the gooey side. These ones were not baked long enough (my other pan was, though), and you can see the tops of some of them are sinking.

When they’re done baking, remove the pans from the oven and allow them to cool completely. And if you call them “muffins,” you can eat them at all hours of the day, whereas if you call them cupcakes, it’s not socially appropriate to eat them for breakfast. So these are muffins, even if they do involve chocolate. And streusel. And cake mix.



  1. Regarding liners, this might be the ultimate in cheapness but I buy the aluminum foil liners. They’re hung right next to the regular paper ones and usually have the same count and the same price, but the foil liners have an inner paper liner too. They’re not attached to each other so I just pull them apart and I get a paper liner and a foil liner – two for the price of one. I haven’t noticed any difference in my muffins or cupcakes regarding how they cook in paper vs foil. I just know I got twice as many liners as the regular pack!

  2. OMG! (Oh MY GOODNESS!) I have been putting off making the Pumpkin Chocolate chip muffins that I’ve promised people at my office multiple times – and NOW I KNOW WHY 🙂

    See.. I just needed this recipe to come out 😉

  3. I just switched from electric to gas as well and my baked goods have generally been finished way earlier than they had been in my old oven. Really not sure if its the fact that it’s gas or just that all ovens are different in general. Can’t wait to try these muffins, they look delicious!

  4. all i can say is… you had me at hello :)! seriously… these look SO yummy – going to make them today! something about streusel and pumpkin… *sigh*…. 🙂

  5. Ok, found out which picture showed up with my muffin recipe! It was the picture for Quick & Easy Noodle Stir-Fry that popped up! Just added that recipe to my box too! 🙂

  6. These look awesome!!! My kids love the regular pumpkin muffins…so I’m sure they will LOVE THESE!!! Can’t wait to make them!! Just added this to my new OBB recipe box, but it came up with the wrong picture…some noodle dish…hmmm…the noodle dish looks yummy too, I’ll have to figure out what it is and make it too!

    LOVE THE NEW recipe box feature…and the shopping list too!!! 🙂 🙂 🙂

    1. Anne, I think you have to click on the recipe title (so it’s the only recipe showing up on the page) and then it will connect the right picture with the recipe. I know that’s annoying. Hopefully we can fix that (and by “we,” I mean the super-smart computer people behind Zip List, not Sara and myself!)

  7. LOVE those cupcake liners, I’ll have to grab some next time I go to Walmart. Muffins look awesome I wish I had one right now for breakfast… it’d go great with my pumpkin spice coffee I’m sipping on right now!

  8. I love the cupcake (uh…I mean muffin) liners! And, I love that you are using that little green bottle in your photo and can hardly wait until mine show up in a few days. I also love that you are using pumpkin pie spice as I have way too much of that at my house, due to buying it several times when I already had some. These sound so fantastic, and I hope you and your new oven resolve your issues with each other soon.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.